Higher levels of palmar surface lactic acid were associated with less hand scaling and greater in vitro pathogen-inactivation activity against influenza A virus and 2 bacterial species in a cross-sectional study.
The study analyzed data from 49 healthy adults aged 20 to 49 years who underwent standardized handwashing and acclimation before skin assessments conducted in January 2018. Investigators measured palmar surface lactic acid, stratum corneum ceramides and amino acids, skin acidity, temperature, and sweat rate. Hand scaling was assessed using a 5-point visual scoring system, while palmar surface extracts were tested in vitro for activity against influenza A/H3N2 virus, Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus aureus. Associations were evaluated using Spearman correlations and partial correlation analyses, with adjustment for multiple comparisons.
Higher palmar lactic acid content was associated with lower hand scaling scores, with a Spearman correlation coefficient of −0.63. Greater antimicrobial activity was also associated with less scaling, with correlation coefficients of −0.57 for influenza A virus, −0.49 for S aureus, and −0.41 for E coli. All associations remained statistically significant after correction for multiple comparisons.
Neither total ceramide nor total amino acid content showed a statistically significant association with hand scaling. However, 3 ceramide classes—NS, ADS, and AS—showed statistically significant inverse associations, with correlation coefficients ranging from −0.33 to −0.45. These findings did not diminish the established roles of ceramides and amino acids in skin hydration and barrier function.
In partial correlation analyses, lactic acid remained positively associated with antimicrobial activity against all 3 pathogens after accounting for skin pH and temperature. In separate models incorporating hand scaling, sweat rate, and skin pH, lactic acid remained associated with greater activity against the pathogens. Its association with lower scaling scores reached statistical significance in 2 models and showed a trend in the third.
The initial associations between antimicrobial activity and hand scaling were no longer statistically significant after adjustment for lactic acid, sweat rate, and skin pH. Lactic acid may be a shared correlate of both outcomes, although the analyses could not establish whether it mediated the relationship.
Palmar lactic acid content was also positively associated with sweat rate, reaching statistical significance in 2 adjusted models and showing a trend in another. Because sweat glands are considered a major source of lactic acid on the skin surface, the authors proposed that sweating may contribute to these levels. Skin pH was also associated with antibacterial activity against E coli and S aureus, whereas no corresponding association was observed for influenza A virus; the authors noted that differences in assay dilution could have influenced this finding.
The study had several limitations. Its cross-sectional design prevented causal inference, and the small sample may have limited detection of weaker associations and generalizability. Potential confounders included moisturizer use, environmental and occupational exposures, hand hygiene practices, underlying dermatologic conditions, and skin microbiome composition. Hand scaling was evaluated by a single assessor without formal testing of intra-rater reliability. Additionally, lactic acid measurements reflected water-extractable surface content rather than secretion rates, and antimicrobial activity was assessed using extracted skin components under laboratory conditions rather than on intact skin. Consequently, the authors noted that these findings could not establish whether modifying palmar lactic acid would improve skin condition or reduce pathogen transmission.
"These potential implications for hand dryness and contact transmission merit further study," wrote lead study author Kenichi Nagano, PhD, of Kao Corporation in Tokyo, Japan, and colleagues.
All authors were employed by Kao Corporation when the study was conducted. The company provided salary support but reported no additional role in the study design, data collection and analysis, publication decision, or manuscript preparation. Two authors retired during peer review. No products in development or on the market were declared.
Source: PLOS One
