Achieving 3-point fixation during complex revision total hip arthroplasty may be associated with a lower risk of acetabular re-revision, while undergoing a third or subsequent revision could increase the risk.
In the retrospective cohort study, investigators included 316 patients who underwent 345 revision total hip arthroplasty procedures involving porous tantalum acetabular components between 2003 and 2024. They analyzed institutional databases, a hospital-based arthroplasty registry, and medical records, with subsequent revisions verified through the Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry. The mean patient age was 71 years and mean follow-up was 6.5 years.
The primary outcome was acetabular re-revision for aseptic loosening, while the secondary outcome was all-cause acetabular re-revision. The investigators estimated cumulative incidence at 2, 5, and 10 years, accounting for mortality as a competing event. Analyses examined Paprosky defect grade, pelvic discontinuity, press-fit fixation, 3-point fixation, and previous revision burden. Multivariable models assessed associations with all-cause re-revision after adjustment for patient and surgical characteristics.
At 10 years, the cumulative incidence of acetabular re-revision for aseptic loosening was 3% vs. 9% for all-cause acetabular re-revision. Corresponding estimates were 1% vs. 6% at 2 years and 2% vs. 7% at 5 years. Overall, 8 components required re-revision for aseptic loosening, whereas 31 underwent re-revision for any cause.
In adjusted analyses of all-cause acetabular re-revision, achieving 3-point fixation was associated with a 63% lower relative likelihood of subsequent revision. Press-fit fixation was associated with lower re-revision risk in unadjusted analyses but was not independently associated with the outcome after adjustment.
Patients undergoing a third or subsequent revision had about 2.7 times the likelihood of all-cause acetabular re-revision compared with those undergoing their first revision. In contrast, Paprosky defect grade was not independently associated with re-revision risk.
At 10 years, the cumulative incidence of all-cause acetabular re-revision was 3%, 9%, 6%, 12%, and 11% for Paprosky 2A, 2B, 2C, 3A, and 3B defects, respectively. Re-revision for aseptic loosening remained uncommon across defect grades, with estimates ranging from 0% for 2A defects to 6% for 3B defects.
Pelvic discontinuity was present in 82 hips, representing 24% of revision procedures. At 10 years, the cumulative incidence of all-cause acetabular re-revision was 17% among hips with pelvic discontinuity vs. 7% among those without it. However, pelvic discontinuity was not independently associated with re-revision after adjustment for other factors.
Further analysis examined the relationship between pelvic discontinuity and fixation status. Among hips with pelvic discontinuity, the 10-year cumulative incidence of all-cause acetabular re-revision was 14% when 3-point fixation was achieved vs. 21% when it was not. Hips with pelvic discontinuity without 3-point fixation had about 3 times the adjusted hazard of re-revision compared with hips without pelvic discontinuity. In contrast, pelvic discontinuity with 3-point fixation was not associated with a statistically significant increase in adjusted re-revision risk.
The investigators acknowledged several limitations. The single-center retrospective design and changes in surgical techniques, implant designs, and institutional practices over the 22-year study period may have influenced outcomes. Just 8 components required re-revision for aseptic loosening, preventing multivariable analysis of the primary outcome. The limited number of failures also reduced the precision of subgroup estimates. All constructs achieving press-fit fixation met the criteria for 3-point fixation, complicating assessment of their independent contributions. Re-revision as an endpoint may have underestimated aseptic loosening among patients who did not undergo further surgery.
Porous tantalum acetabular components may provide durable reconstruction across varying degrees of acetabular bone loss. Although defect severity was not independently associated with all-cause re-revision, achieving 3-point fixation and previous revision burden were associated with subsequent outcomes.
"Our findings suggest that stable acetabular reconstruction depends less on the extent of bone loss and more on achieving adequate initial component fixation," wrote lead study author Taisha M. D’Apollonio, of Adelaide University in Australia, and colleagues.
Full disclosures of the study authors can be found in the study.
Source: The Journal of Arthroplasty
