Frequent sleep starts, commonly known as hypnic jerks, were associated with poorer sleep quality, greater insomnia severity, and higher anxiety symptoms in a cross-sectional online survey of 194 adults. Sleep quality, dysfunctional sleep-related beliefs, and anxiety were independently associated with episode frequency, although the findings could not establish whether these factors contributed to sleep starts or resulted from them.
The study analyzed anonymous online survey responses collected between June 2020 and January 2021 from adults recruited in Austria and Germany through mailing lists, flyers, social media, and contacts with general practitioners and rehabilitation clinics. Of the 194 participants, 96 met the study's criteria for at least weekly sleep starts, including sudden awakenings at sleep onset and at least 1 additional symptom, while 98 reported less frequent or no episodes.
The mean age was 32.8 years, and 148 participants were women. Investigators excluded participants with self-reported conditions that could confound sleep-start symptoms, including restless legs syndrome, periodic limb movement disorder, sleep apnea, epilepsy, Parkinson disease, and other neurological or cardiological conditions.
The authors examined sleep-start experiences and their associations with demographic, sleep-related, and psychological characteristics. Standardized questionnaires assessed sleep quality, insomnia severity, daytime sleepiness, dysfunctional sleep-related beliefs, and symptoms of anxiety and depression. Additional questions developed for this study assessed motor, sensory, emotional, cognitive, and autonomic experiences, as well as perceived triggers and consequences. Group comparisons, correlation analyses, and hierarchical regression models were used to evaluate associations, with age and gender included as covariates.
Participants reporting weekly sleep starts had poorer overall sleep quality, with mean Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index scores of 7.21 vs 5.19 in the comparison group. Insomnia Severity Index scores were also higher, averaging 10.67 vs 5.55, representing the largest difference among the principal sleep and psychological measures.
Sleep-related cognitions and psychological symptoms showed similar differences. Dysfunctional sleep-related belief scores averaged 64.84 in the weekly sleep-start group vs 51.85 in the comparison group, while anxiety symptom scores on the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale averaged 7.69 vs 5.65. Depression symptom scores were also higher (5.19 vs 3.45), although depressive symptoms were not independently associated with episode frequency in the adjusted analysis.
Participants with weekly sleep starts also reported lower sleep efficiency (82.9% vs 88%), longer sleep-onset latency (33.90 vs 25.60 minutes), and shorter total sleep time (6.74 vs 7.07 hours). Daytime sleepiness did not differ significantly between groups.
Within the weekly sleep-start group, episode frequency was positively correlated with poorer overall sleep quality, greater insomnia severity, stronger dysfunctional sleep-related beliefs, and higher anxiety symptoms. Associations with sleep efficiency, sleep-onset latency, total sleep time, daytime sleepiness, and depression were not statistically significant.
In hierarchical regression analyses, poorer sleep quality, stronger dysfunctional sleep-related beliefs, and higher anxiety symptoms remained independently associated with more frequent sleep starts. Younger age was also associated with higher episode frequency, whereas gender and depressive symptoms were not significant predictors. The final model explained 26.9% of the variation in log-transformed sleep-start frequency.
Sleep starts involved more than involuntary muscle movements, with participants reporting sensory, emotional, cognitive, and autonomic experiences. Among the 96 participants reporting weekly episodes, 87.5% described muscle jerks or twitches, 74% reported dream-like experiences during sleep onset, and 65.6% reported sensations of falling or losing stability. Somatosensory symptoms, including tingling and numbness, were reported by 63.5%, while 62.5% described palpitations or rapid breathing.
Visual phenomena, such as flashes or flickering with closed eyes, were reported by 47.9%, and 21.9% described auditory experiences involving loud or explosive sounds.
Emotional responses were also common. Alarm and confusion were each reported by 79.2% of participants, anxiety by 74%, and panic or perceived immediate threat by 71.9%. Neutral emotional responses were reported by 76%, indicating variability in how participants experienced these events. Sleep-related cognitive experiences included pressure to fall asleep, reported by 83.3%, and preoccupation with personal concerns, reported by 80.2%.
Although 95.8% reported being able to return to sleep quickly at least occasionally, 76% also described episodes of becoming fully awake and experiencing difficulty resuming sleep. Approximately 51% perceived that sleep starts prolonged sleep-onset latency, while 40.6% reported no change. Fear of recurrence was reported by 39.6%.
Participants retrospectively associated more frequent sleep starts with psychological stress, emotional tension, and increased mental burden. Relaxation was perceived as reducing episode frequency, whereas sleep deprivation was less consistently identified as an influencing factor.
Exploratory analyses indicated that women were slightly overrepresented in the weekly sleep-start group. Participants in this group also reported higher rates of sleep disorders, nightmares, and personal concerns. No statistically significant group differences were identified for diagnosed anxiety, depression, posttraumatic stress disorder, occupational concerns, or substance use.
Sensitivity analyses using alternative thresholds for sleep-start frequency generally supported the main findings, although differences in total sleep time and associations involving age, depression, insomnia severity, and anxiety were less consistent. Associations involving overall sleep quality and dysfunctional sleep-related beliefs remained comparatively consistent.
The authors acknowledged that the cross-sectional design and reliance on retrospective self-reported data prevented conclusions about causality or the temporal relationship between sleep starts and psychological characteristics. No objective sleep measurements were obtained, and the study-specific questions assessing sleep-start experiences had not undergone formal psychometric validation.
The findings also could not reliably distinguish sleep starts from related sleep-onset phenomena, including exploding head syndrome and hypnagogic hallucinations. The threshold defining weekly episodes was established post hoc, following data inspection, and some associations varied under alternative classifications. Convenience sampling and participant self-selection further limited generalizability and prevented population prevalence estimation.
Associations with subjective sleep quality and dysfunctional sleep-related beliefs were more consistent than those involving total sleep time or daytime sleepiness, the researchers concluded. They emphasized the need for longitudinal and experimental studies incorporating objective sleep measurements to clarify the mechanisms underlying these associations.
“These findings support the view that SS should be considered within broader frameworks of sleep-related hyperarousal and cognitive-emotional activation,” wrote lead study author Tanja Grünberger, PhD, MSc, of the Department of Psychology at Paris-Lodron University Salzburg, Austria, and colleagues.
The authors reported no competing interests. The study received no specific funding.
Source: PLOS Mental Health
