Higher sensation-seeking was associated with more variable choices, lower reward performance, and context-dependent tolerance of uncertain stimulation in a study of reward-guided choices. Researchers also found that sensation-seeking and impulsivity showed opposing associations with avoidance of uncertain visual stimulation. The findings suggested that the 2 personality traits may be associated with distinct mechanisms of reward-guided decision-making.
The study, published in Communications Psychology, combined an exploratory reanalysis of previously collected experimental data with a preregistered online experiment. Experiment 1 reanalyzed data from 2 studies involving 73 adults who completed reward-learning tasks involving probabilistic, nonpainful electrical stimulation, including 67 with available sensation-seeking scores. Experiment 2 recruited 619 adults from the US and United Kingdom through an online research platform, with 527 included in the final analysis following exclusions. Participants in Experiment 2 were aged 18 to 80 years, with a mean age of 39.8 years, and completed 4 rounds of a computerized task involving reward learning and visual stimulation. Participants chose between objects associated with different reward levels and probabilities of receiving a 1.4-second colored spinning animation. Stimulation probabilities were set at 15%, 50%, or 85%, independently of reward.
The authors examined whether expected stimulation, uncertainty about stimulation, or their interaction explained reward-guided choices. Expected stimulation referred to the learned probability that an option would produce sensory stimulation, whereas stimulation uncertainty reflected how unpredictable that outcome was. Uncertainty was greatest when stimulation was equally likely to occur or not occur. Outcomes included reward performance, choice variability, sensitivity to expected rewards, and avoidance of stimulation uncertainty. Sensation-seeking and impulsivity were assessed using standardized questionnaires, while computational learning models estimated how participants incorporated reward and stimulation information into their decisions.
In Experiment 2, higher sensation-seeking scores were associated with broader sampling across available choices and lower average rewards. Although participants generally improved their performance with practice, those with higher sensation-seeking scores consistently earned fewer rewards. Impulsivity was not significantly associated with either reward performance or choice variability.
In the online experiment, participants generally avoided options associated with greater uncertainty about stimulation. However, higher sensation-seeking scores were associated with weaker uncertainty avoidance, whereas higher impulsivity scores were associated with stronger uncertainty avoidance. The difference between these associations was statistically significant, suggesting that the 2 traits were linked to distinct patterns of uncertainty-related decision-making.
Higher sensation-seeking was also associated with reduced sensitivity to expected rewards, whereas impulsivity showed no statistically significant association with reward sensitivity. Both traits were associated with a reduced tendency to repeat the same response position, suggesting a shared pattern in response repetition despite their different relationships with reward and uncertainty.
Additional analyses found that participants with higher sensation-seeking scores missed more trials and that higher omission rates were associated with poorer performance. However, the association between sensation-seeking and lower reward performance persisted after adjustment for omissions. Reaction-time analyses found no significant association between sensation-seeking and overall response speed.
Computational modeling further indicated that higher sensation-seeking was associated with greater choice stochasticity, reflecting less consistent selection based on modeled option values. However, sensation-seeking was not significantly associated with uncertainty weighting when that parameter was examined independently after adjustment for other traits and demographic characteristics.
In exploratory analyses, the association between sensation-seeking and uncertainty avoidance depended on how participants weighted expected stimulation. When expected-stimulation weighting was low, higher sensation-seeking was associated with greater tolerance of uncertain stimulation. When expected-stimulation weighting was high, higher sensation-seeking was associated with stronger uncertainty avoidance.
Impulsivity showed an opposing interaction pattern, with stronger uncertainty avoidance primarily observed when expected-stimulation weighting was low. The difference between the 2 traits was statistically significant. These findings suggested that sensation-seeking was not characterized by a uniform preference for uncertainty. Rather, its relationship with uncertainty depended on how participants valued expected stimulation.
Participants generally rated the visual stimulation as pleasant and moderately arousing. Higher sensation-seeking was associated with greater reported arousal, whereas higher impulsivity was associated with lower pleasantness and arousal ratings. These subjective responses did not explain the distinct computational patterns associated with the 2 traits.
Results from Experiment 1 provided additional evidence for the role of stimulation uncertainty. A computational model incorporating uncertainty predicted participants' choices better than models based on expected stimulation alone. Higher sensation-seeking was associated with less negative uncertainty weighting, suggesting reduced avoidance of uncertain stimulation. However, expected stimulation and uncertainty were closely correlated in the original experimental design, preventing the authors from reliably separating their independent contributions.
The study had other limitations. Experiment 2 used a simplified visual stimulation task that may not reflect complex real-world decisions involving substance use, gambling, or social risk-taking. Subjective responses to stimulation were measured rather than experimentally manipulated, and computational estimates of choice variability could reflect multiple underlying processes, including imperfect learning or unmeasured decision factors. Both experiments involved adults, limiting conclusions about developmental differences. Several interaction analyses were exploratory, and no adjustments were made for multiple statistical comparisons. The researchers also modified a preregistered performance-based exclusion criterion in Experiment 2.
The findings suggested that sensation-seeking and impulsivity may involve distinct computational mechanisms rather than representing different degrees of a shared tendency toward risk-taking. The results did not establish whether these decision-making patterns produce beneficial or harmful outcomes outside the experimental setting.
“The central finding was that sensation-seeking was not reducible to expected-stimulation seeking or to a general preference for uncertainty,” wrote lead study author Ern Wong, PhD, of the IMT School for Advanced Studies Lucca, Lucca, Italy, and colleagues.
Tobias U. Hauser reported consulting for Limbic Ltd and holding company share options, unrelated to the study. The remaining authors declared no competing interests.
Source: Communications Psychology
