Children aged 5 to 9 years preferred learning from peers who achieved success through personal effort rather than those who received similar outcomes through external assistance. Their preferences extended to information-seeking and interpersonal decisions, suggesting that children may consider how success is achieved when evaluating potential sources of knowledge and social partners.
Researchers conducted 2 studies involving 220 English-speaking children aged 5 to 9 years recruited from preschools and a science museum in the Boston area. Study 1 included 100 children who evaluated 2 peers possessing identical Lego toys: a "striver" who spent time independently building the toy and an "endowed" peer who received a toy from a sibling. Study 2 included 120 children and varied the desirability of the toys obtained by the striver and endowed peer to examine whether achievement outcomes influenced children's preferences.
The authors assessed children's preferences for learning from the striver or endowed peer. Study 1 examined learning decisions involving Lego-related knowledge and unfamiliar object labels, alongside judgments of competence. Study 2 evaluated preferences for seeking future information, learning new information, and interpersonal interactions, including sharing, collaboration, and friendship. Researchers also collected children's explanations for their decisions to examine the roles of effort and perceived knowledge.
In Study 2, children selected the striver as a source of future information in 84.1% of decisions, preferred learning from the striver in 70%, and favored the striver in 75% of interpersonal choices. All 3 preferences exceeded chance levels. Increasing age was associated with stronger preferences for the striver in information-seeking and interpersonal decisions, although this relationship was not statistically significant for learning preferences.
The desirability of the striver's achievement also influenced children's choices. Compared with strivers who achieved less desirable outcomes, those who achieved desirable outcomes had approximately 5.39 times the odds of being selected for future information seeking, 2 times the odds of being selected for learning, and 3 times the odds of being preferred for interpersonal interactions. In contrast, the outcome achieved by the endowed peer was not significantly associated with children's preferences.
Study 1 demonstrated a similar preference for effort-based achievement. Children selected the striver in 60.6% of Lego-related learning decisions and 57.6% of decisions involving unfamiliar object labels. Both preferences exceeded chance levels. Increasing age was associated with a greater likelihood of selecting the striver in Lego-related learning tasks, and children who favored the striver in these tasks were more likely to extend that preference to also favor the striver in unfamiliar object-labeling tasks.
Children also attributed greater competence to the striver. In Study 1, they rated the striver as competent in 71.6% of assessments and selected the striver as more competent than the endowed peer in 73.3% of direct comparisons. However, these judgments varied by activity. Children were more likely to attribute competence to the striver in tasks resembling the original Lego-building context than in unrelated labeling tasks.
Children's explanations in Study 2 provided additional insight into their preferences. References to effort were associated with selecting the striver across information-seeking, learning, and interpersonal decisions. References to perceived knowledge were also associated with information-seeking and interpersonal preferences, but only effort-related explanations significantly predicted learning preferences.
The authors interpreted these findings as suggesting that children may view personal effort as both an indicator of competence and a desirable characteristic independent of demonstrated knowledge. Although children considered successful outcomes, their preferences were not determined solely by achievement. The findings also suggested that children distinguished between competence demonstrated in a particular activity and broader expertise.
Several limitations warrant consideration. Participants were recruited from a Western cultural setting that emphasizes individual achievement and personal effort, potentially limiting generalizability to societies where collective support and communal achievement are valued differently. The sample also consisted predominantly of children from middle- to high-income households. Additionally, the experimental scenarios could not fully distinguish children's evaluations of effort from their perceptions of demonstrated competence, because the striver had independently completed the Lego-building activity. The findings may also be specific to the age range examined.
"These findings highlight that children consider the unequal means to success when making learning decisions, and may view effort as a reliable indicator of epistemic credibility," wrote lead study author Nina N. Ye, of the Wheelock College of Education & Human Development at Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts, and colleagues.
The authors reported no competing interests.
Source: Communications Psychology
