Objective:
To examine whether children aged 5–9 prefer learning from and interacting with peers who achieved success through personal effort rather than external assistance.
Approach:
- Participants and design: Two studies included 220 English-speaking children recruited from preschools and a science museum in the Boston area.
- Study 1: Children compared a peer who independently built a Lego toy with one who received a similar toy from a sibling. Researchers assessed learning choices and judgments of competence.
- Study 2: Researchers varied the desirability of the peers’ outcomes and assessed choices about information-seeking, learning, sharing, collaboration, and friendship, as well as children’s explanations.
Key Findings:
- In Study 1, children chose the effortful achiever for Lego-related learning in 60.6% of decisions and for unfamiliar object labels in 57.6%; both rates exceeded chance.
- Children attributed competence to the effortful achiever in 71.6% of assessments and favored that peer in 73.3% of direct competence comparisons. Competence judgments were stronger for tasks resembling Lego building.
- In Study 2, children chose the effortful achiever for future information in 84.1% of decisions, learning in 70%, and interpersonal choices in 75%; all exceeded chance.
- More desirable outcomes for the effortful achiever were associated with higher odds of being selected for information-seeking, learning, and interpersonal choices. The endowed peer’s outcome was not significantly associated with preferences.
- Effort-related explanations were associated with choosing the effortful achiever across decision types. Perceived-knowledge explanations were associated with information-seeking and interpersonal choices, but not learning preferences.
Interpretation:
The authors suggest that children may treat personal effort as an indicator of competence and as a desirable characteristic beyond demonstrated knowledge. Preferences were influenced by outcomes but were not determined solely by them.
Limitations:
- Participants came from a Western cultural setting that emphasizes individual achievement and effort, and were predominantly from middle- to high-income households.
- The scenarios could not fully separate evaluations of effort from perceptions of demonstrated competence.
- Findings may be specific to the age range studied.
Conclusion:
Children in these studies often preferred peers whose success followed personal effort, including as sources of information and as social partners.
Sources:
This content is an AI-generated, fully rewritten summary based on a published scholarly article. It does not reproduce the original text and is not a substitute for the original publication. Readers are encouraged to consult the source for full context, data, and methodology.
